Commenting Preference:
The author encourages honest critique.
Re: Pilcrow
Anonymous
7th Dec 2012 9:25pm
I think "stately" and "sing" could be the wrong way around. I like "in" as opposed to "on a gloomy winter's day"; it evokes the feeling of waking up inside winter, as if it's a room or cocoon, which is more effective. Thanks for the read.
0
re: Re: Pilcrow
8th Dec 2012 7:31pm
Re: Pilcrow
Anonymous
7th Dec 2012 9:33pm
<< post removed >>
re: Re: Pilcrow
8th Dec 2012 7:32pm
Re: Pilcrow
Anonymous
8th Dec 2012 7:02pm
i agree about 'in' being a more effective choice. never a disappointment here. :]
1
Re: Pilcrow
opheliac!
One thing which leaves me speechless are the n-number of dimensions , characters , settings..all floating freely to be interpreted in such small compactness of ur verses!
never do I return from ur pages unamazed & its here, the content!! that's the key-word for me weighing tonnes generating from the catalyst man to inspire even the cold nature n sliding tones of birdie. Your words indeed does the same magic to me each tym Ophie, in such small space!
keep up ur unique art dear.
thank you much:)
One thing which leaves me speechless are the n-number of dimensions , characters , settings..all floating freely to be interpreted in such small compactness of ur verses!
never do I return from ur pages unamazed & its here, the content!! that's the key-word for me weighing tonnes generating from the catalyst man to inspire even the cold nature n sliding tones of birdie. Your words indeed does the same magic to me each tym Ophie, in such small space!
keep up ur unique art dear.
thank you much:)
0
re: Re: Pilcrow
15th Dec 2012 11:08am
My Oh my! Uma i don't think i deserve this... Not because im too modest but because don't feel worthy of such praise. Nevertheless im so grateful for your ever so kind words and encouragement :)
Stay Safe and Thank YOU!!!
Stay Safe and Thank YOU!!!
Re: Pilcrow
15th Dec 2012 12:12pm
You keep it so short and sweet, always leaving room for insight and the reader's imagination. Beautiful work.
1
re: Re: Pilcrow
15th Dec 2012 12:15pm
Re: Pilcrow
22nd Dec 2012 2:41am
Sorry, opheliac, but I don't grasp, understand this poem. Ar first I thought the man was dreaming: but then how could he be "whistling?" I can understand how any of us can facilitate a bird to chirp, but "cause, especially a bird outside where I presume this poem is occuring. Well. . .I'm not sure where the poem is taking place. I love the last two lines but they seem disconnected from the first two.. To me you have something in this poem but you are not expressing it so, at least this reader, gets it.
marcella1
marcella1
0
re: Re: Pilcrow
22nd Dec 2012 7:27pm
No the man is not dreaming at all. The man wakes up content - despite his gloomy nature- so he whistles. Due to his delightful whistling, the bird's chirping can't be compared with him. The paradox occurs when he wakes up content on a gloomy winter's day. I hope this makes things easier for you to understand:) Feel free to ask further questions nevertheless.
Re: Pilcrow
23rd Dec 2012 5:00pm
These verses are beautiful.
I read your words as if they were Haiku. Precious Haiku.
Merry Christmas, sweetie.
Lucaxxx
I read your words as if they were Haiku. Precious Haiku.
Merry Christmas, sweetie.
Lucaxxx
0
re: Re: Pilcrow
24th Dec 2012 1:04pm
They started as a Haiku to be honest but ended up as nothing like Haiku!
Merry Christmas to you too Luca :)
Merry Christmas to you too Luca :)
Re: Pilcrow
12th Jan 2013 3:05pm
I am inclined to think you might be standing back a little too aloof on this one Hun. Whistling right out of the gate seems misplaced, like it would fit better at the end maybe ?
let me think on this some more :)
let me think on this some more :)
0
re: Re: Pilcrow
12th Jan 2013 11:57pm
i appreciate you reading and taking the time to comment. I'd love to hear what you have to say for this poem. Feedback is greatly appreciated!