deepundergroundpoetry.com
SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
He has a heart whose fabric is so soft
and longs for fingers that appreciate it
by giving touches that confirm its force
which never skimps on gifts for those who need.
His heart relates its joy to those around.
It yearns to feed the others ere it eats.
When birds knock hungry beaks on his glass panes,
he leaves his food to endow them some seeds.
He asks the old, the weak, to come to him,
not only to feed them, but gratify
his heart that loves to give the hungry ones
whether they are humane or fierce in miens.
BY JOSEPH ZENIEH
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
____________________________________
He has a heart whose fabric is so soft
and longs for fingers that appreciate it
by giving touches that confirm its force
which never skimps on gifts for those who need.
His heart relates its joy to those around.
It yearns to feed the others ere it eats.
When birds knock hungry beaks on his glass panes,
he leaves his food to endow them some seeds.
He asks the old, the weak, to come to him,
not only to feed them, but gratify
his heart that loves to give the hungry ones
whether they are humane or fierce in miens.
BY JOSEPH ZENIEH
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
____________________________________
All writing remains the property of the author. Don't use it for any purpose without their permission.
likes 3
reading list entries 1
comments 17
reads 366
Commenting Preference:
The author encourages honest critique.
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
10th Oct 2020 10:22pm
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
10th Oct 2020 10:47pm
Thank you very much, Lozzamus, for your appreciation. This is great encouragement to me.
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
10th Oct 2020 10:52pm
Given the syntax of these lines:
He has a heart whose fabric is so soft
and longs for fingers that appreciate it
You are claiming that fabric longs for fingers that appreciate it.
And give the syntax here:
His heart relates its joy to those around.
It yearns to feed the others ere it eats.
You are claiming that the heart of the person you are speaking about "eats".
And these lines:
He asks the old, the weak, to come to him,
not only to feed them, but [to] gratify
his heart
make the grammar gaffed claim that the reason he wants others to come to him is grounded in a desire to be pleasured.
He has a heart whose fabric is so soft
and longs for fingers that appreciate it
You are claiming that fabric longs for fingers that appreciate it.
And give the syntax here:
His heart relates its joy to those around.
It yearns to feed the others ere it eats.
You are claiming that the heart of the person you are speaking about "eats".
And these lines:
He asks the old, the weak, to come to him,
not only to feed them, but [to] gratify
his heart
make the grammar gaffed claim that the reason he wants others to come to him is grounded in a desire to be pleasured.
0
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
10th Oct 2020 11:22pm
Re: Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
"Nothing is worth answering, Baldwin."
So you say.
But why should anyone trust your judgment on this matter without some explicit demonstration from you that the remarks I made are not true and that the way you have set out your lines do not contain the problems of coherence that I claimed they do?
So you say.
But why should anyone trust your judgment on this matter without some explicit demonstration from you that the remarks I made are not true and that the way you have set out your lines do not contain the problems of coherence that I claimed they do?
0
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
The first two suggestions need some imagination to understand poetry. I am very glad that my readers have this imagination, and they started answering you.
Not only to feed them but gratify ...
To: can be omitted after the COORDINATOR, but. I previously explained that to you.
Not only to feed them but gratify ...
To: can be omitted after the COORDINATOR, but. I previously explained that to you.
Re: Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
11th Oct 2020 4:06pm
Ah yes, the old "it's your fault that you don't understand my 'poetry'. It's all due to your lack of "imagination". There is absolutely no possibility that your lack of understanding is due to your writing poorly since that is something that's impossible for you to do! (Sarcasm).
But the fact that you say that one has to use imagination to understand what you write means that you have failed to do what is essential to good poetry -- clear and effective communication that does not demand that readers fill in what you perhaps intended to convey
And the issue is not whether "to" is syntactically implied, but what you've conveyed is that your speaker does what he does because he wants to pleasure himself. Thanks for missing my point and dwelling on a secondary matter.
And your "readerS" who have started "answering" me? It looks like you've got two at most. And they have hardly shown by specifying how and why what I've said about your submissions is not on point. And that's what "answering" me entails. In any case, why should anyone take what they say with any degree of seriousness? What makes you think they possess the critical acumen that is necessary to see what separates good writing from the bad?
But the fact that you say that one has to use imagination to understand what you write means that you have failed to do what is essential to good poetry -- clear and effective communication that does not demand that readers fill in what you perhaps intended to convey
And the issue is not whether "to" is syntactically implied, but what you've conveyed is that your speaker does what he does because he wants to pleasure himself. Thanks for missing my point and dwelling on a secondary matter.
And your "readerS" who have started "answering" me? It looks like you've got two at most. And they have hardly shown by specifying how and why what I've said about your submissions is not on point. And that's what "answering" me entails. In any case, why should anyone take what they say with any degree of seriousness? What makes you think they possess the critical acumen that is necessary to see what separates good writing from the bad?
0
Re: Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
"The first two suggestions need some imagination to understand poetry. "
So the key to understanding all poetry is to apply some "needed" imagination to the first two "suggestions" (or was it remarks?) I made about how the syntax of certain of your lines makes you end up saying some strange things?
That's the claim of your remark!
And it would take a great deal of imagination on a reader's part to see that the antecedent of "it" in your line that reads "It yearns to feed the others ere it eats" is not "heart".
So the key to understanding all poetry is to apply some "needed" imagination to the first two "suggestions" (or was it remarks?) I made about how the syntax of certain of your lines makes you end up saying some strange things?
That's the claim of your remark!
And it would take a great deal of imagination on a reader's part to see that the antecedent of "it" in your line that reads "It yearns to feed the others ere it eats" is not "heart".
0
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
11th Oct 2020 3:48pm
Lovely, JZ. Waking with a song of gratitude, or giving daily gratitude is so important in our everyday lives. I think you've penned out the perfect welcome mat for a weary heart to come and rest.
0
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
11th Oct 2020 5:54pm
Thank you very much, Ahavati, for your extremely kind and poetic commit. It's a very beautiful comment.
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
Baldwin says:he wants to pleasure himself.
What do you mean by saying, TO PLEASURE himself? Do you mean TO PLEASE himself. If you do, yes l mean it. The person here finds pleasure in feeding more than eating.
What do you mean by saying, TO PLEASURE himself? Do you mean TO PLEASE himself. If you do, yes l mean it. The person here finds pleasure in feeding more than eating.
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
11th Oct 2020 7:15pm
But you didn't say that the man you speak of finds pleasure in doing what he does. You said he does it to consciously and intentionally **gratify** himself. According to your wording, the man you speak of has a selfish reason for doing what he does. What motivates him is hedonism rather than altruism.
BTW, if you are quoting me, you should have written Baldwin says "he wants to pleasure himself". A colon is not a quotation mark.
Cue the reply that focuses on this incidental remark of mine, and not on my main contention.
BTW, if you are quoting me, you should have written Baldwin says "he wants to pleasure himself". A colon is not a quotation mark.
Cue the reply that focuses on this incidental remark of mine, and not on my main contention.
0
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
11th Oct 2020 8:36pm
Joseph this is a beautifully heartfelt poem. I love it's harmonious flow and proportion, the subtle depth of its details. Beautiful work.
0
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
11th Oct 2020 8:45pm
Thank you very much, Daniel, for your very kind comment. I really appreciate your comments because l like your experience as a poet, and l like you as a dear friend.
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
I wonder if you realize that in saying this:
He has a heart whose fabric is so soft
and longs for fingers that appreciate it
by giving touches that confirm its force
you have presented the person of whom you speak as someone who is in dire need of constant affirmation as well as a man who wants to be gratified?
.
He has a heart whose fabric is so soft
and longs for fingers that appreciate it
by giving touches that confirm its force
you have presented the person of whom you speak as someone who is in dire need of constant affirmation as well as a man who wants to be gratified?
.
0
Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
12th Oct 2020 9:34pm
Re: Re. SAY A WORD OF GRATITUDE.
But we don't all long for it. And besides that, you said "finger touches" not a"word".
0